[Verse 1]
It’s not the same when I’m with you
You open up, I fall right through
Came out a different shade of blue
It’s not the same when I’m with you

[Chorus]
But it's always a surprise when
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
The tide comes in
When the tide comes in
But it’s always a surprise when
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
You call again
When you call again
[Verse 2]
How long’s the shoreline anyway
I measured every other day
Tide washes all my work away
How long’s the shoreline anyway

[Chorus]
But it's always a surprise whеn
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
The tidе comes in
When the tide comes in
But it’s always a surprise when
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
You call again
When you call again

[Chorus]
But it's always a surprise when
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
The tide comes in
When the tide comes in
But it’s always a surprise when
Oh, it’s always a surprise when
You call again
When you call again
[Outro]
Oh, I’m not supposed to answer
I’m not supposed to know
Oh, I’ll let the silence answer
I’ve got to let it go
Oh, I’m not supposed to answer
I’m not supposed to know
Oh, I’ll let the silence answer
I’ve got to let it go now